Entry: LOOKING FOR A NEW COMPLIANT PALESTINIAN ELITE 6.25.2007



In the course of Empire, colonialism, and the domination of Western Hegemony over the Middle East there are very few things over the last few hundred years that are new - in fact, there is nothing new. Men like Abbas and Dahlan clamor like they always have for both money and power, the eternal cry of colonialism is always divide and conquer.

So when the United States proposed it's ideas of Hamas and Fatah duking it out for who the top dog would be, and than arming the most servile faction, Fatah had to win the new low in the conflicts sordid history. This is because Fatah has always seen itself as merely the instrument of policing the Palestinians while the Israelis were allowed to expand their occupation.



The battle did not work out as intended, as conceived in the minds of men like Elliot Abrams, so there has been a movement to plan B. Plan B is not something new, it has been used by colonialism from the beginning - make a new "privileged" Palestinian, a sort of elite that gets to have a modicum of dignity and perhaps own some property of it's own.

You can see this play out no matter where you look in colonial enterprises in the past, a sort of fat developed around the midsection of the colonial that wishes to exploit the "native."  In India the "raj" set up special territory for the people who were supposed to be the "cut above," which in reality meant they were the most pliant, as long as they were allowed to have their little piece of property and their "privileges (few though they were)."


(Author of the road map to nowhere)

What this all boils down to is corruption, and the desire for some form of normalcy (deformity) for the people, at the expense of their "less fortunate" counterparts. Soon there may even be conversations in the West Bank of how bad they feel about "those people over there," and why can't the individuals who are their leaders do something to make their "life easier." It is similar to the structure you see in the United States which is much more fluid, but the contrast will be much sharper in this scenario.

They give the impression that they are going to award them, but the only thing they  may receive is just a portion of the tax monies which the Israeli government has withheld contrary to law. The occupier believes that he can isolate the Palestinians, which is just another form of division for the benefit of the occupier. The impression that will be left is that all of the Palestinians could have benefited, but now it has become "apparent" that only the compliant ones "deserve" better treatment.


(West Bank)

The idea being broached here is that an emergency government is possible, and that even though it crosses the Basic Law (2004) anything goes at this juncture.  So the colonial power, and it's extended power which is the USA wants them to follow the same formula of lawlessness and to gut the democratically elected government.

As Omar Barghouti has said in his article on June 20th, in the Electronic Intifada "...the bloody clash between the Islamist group, and it's secular counterpart, Fatah, and irrespective of motives, has descended into a feud between two slaves fighting over the crumbs thrown to them, whenever they behave, by their common colonial master."  This will never lead to self- determination nor liberation.  The only thing that will come from this is the destruction of any PA structure


(Gaza)

There is still an illegal wall surrounding all, and the Israelis have no intention but the complete destruction of the Palestinian people - either in the West Bank or Gaza.  What is not needed is some perceived advantage or privilege to calcify so that the Palestinian people begin to abandon each other.  They do not need to fall into the all to common trap which has been used for years by colonialists - indeed a division, but one thinking that it is better off than the other.  YOU CANNOT ALLOW A SPLIT TO OCCUR BETWEEN THE PALESTINIANS IN OCCUPIED TERRITORY, FROM THE REFUGEES, AND THE PALESTINIAN CITIZENS IN ISRAEL.  THE ONLY PALESTINE THAT WILL FINALLY WIN IS A UNIFIED ONE,  AND NO LEADER NOR CORNER OF ANY PORTION OF THE PA CAN AFFORD TO BE SET APART FROM ONE ANOTHER.  IF YOU THINK ARE SPECIAL AND THAT YOU WILL BE SPARED, LET THESE WORDS RING IN YOUR EARS  - "YOU WILL BE NEXT."

WHAT WE FACE

DON'T SELL OUT TO THE NIGHT

TEN THOUSAND FISTS

CITY

IT TAKES GREAT LOVE TO BE A REVOLUTIONARY

CALLING YOU

THE LONG LIE

THIS WILL NOT CONTINUE!

PEACE, PROPAGANDA, AND THE PROMISED LAND - PART 1

PEACE, PROPAGANDA, AND THE PROMISED LAND - PART 2

We must always keep in mind, that at points of crisis in the colonial cycle historically, that these have been the times of change for the best, as Antonius has said in his work "The Arab Awakening:"

"It often happens in the history of nations that a conflict
of oppossing forces which seems destined to end in
the triumph of the stronger party is given an unspecified
twist by the emergence of new forces which owe their
emergence to that very triumph."

   2 comments

deadringer
June 26, 2007   01:20 PM PDT
 
Bret, I want to let you know that I appreciate you stopping by to voice your view. Of course, we do not share the same in regard to a "notional" view of a viable Palestinian state.

Israel has been able to survive because it has been the willing accomplice of Western Hegemony, and it's ability to hide behind a superpower to circumvent (break) international law with impunity. The PA has NEVER been an "autonomous entity," but has had a power which is purely derivative to the whim of a dominant colonial (Israel). The good largesse which you mention is merely what has been due an occupied people under international law and the conventions (seeing that the USA is the indiscriminate supporter of a brutal and illegal occupation, support is merely their duty) - along with a murderous and illegal occupation, which has tried to choke the life out of the Palestinians. Palestine has had one great obsticle, that is Israel - who under the whole charade of a "peace process" has done nothing but dash repeatedly any Palestinian hope or will for a sovereign independent nation born of solid liberation. In fact, I can say without equivocation, that what Israel over the years has feared more that anything else is the outbreak of peace!

You may not be aware of this, but in the annals of colonial history it is a breaking point of this nature which finally brings new means and final liberation. So, rather than looking with doom and gloom (which you are assuming and encouraging) I am looking forward to a new direction, the force of which Israel will be vanquished.

Unlike many, I am aware of, if not anything else, the geographical (as well as political and economic) situation of this region does not give any room for a two state solution. So the nonsense of being a Jewish state, and at the same time calling yourself a democracy will have to cease, and a final state with equality will have to be established. So you look forward to the "death of the Palestinian dream," I look forward to the birth of a new nation. History is on my side, unless of course Israel tries to go the way of absolute genocide - and if it does, it will be stopped by an ouraged world.

Once again, thanks for stopping by to share.
Bret Stephens
June 26, 2007   06:30 AM PDT
 
<b>No matter how much diplomatic, military and financial oxygen is pumped into Mahmoud Abbas's Palestinian Authority, it's oxygen flowing to a corpse. Palestine has always been a notional place, a field of dreams belonging only to those who know how to keep it. Israelis have held on to their state because they were able to develop the political, military and economic institutions that a state requires to survive, beginning with its monopoly on the use of legitimate force. In its nearly 14 years as an autonomous entity, the PA has succeeded in none of that, despite being on the receiving end of unprecedented international goodwill and largesse.

"Palestine," as we know it today, will revert to what it was--shadowland between Israel and its neighbors--and Palestinians, as we know them today, will revert to who they were: Arabs.

Whether there might have been a better outcome is anyone's guess. But the dream that was Palestine is finally dead. </b>

Leave a Comment:

Name


Homepage (optional)


Comments